Lowered standards push Barcelona to the brink
Anyone who has taken any kind of evangelical joy from the quality of football which FC Barcelona have been playing since autumn 2008 will have been distressed, perhaps traumatized, by what they watched on Saturday.
The fact the Spanish champions lost to Real Valladolid is relevant to who wins the title this season, relevant to whether the Pucela avoid relegation or not ... but it is not the main issue for Barça.
There were large chunks of the match when Barça´s players were regularly unable to pass accurately to each other; not a whiff of the type of basketball-style, rapid circulation where the ball whizzes between one, two, three or four players in the matter of seconds until either the danger they are under dissipates or the defensive blockage they face is shredded.
Barça players, unable to pass accurately.
Then, just as stark, some of the poor passing might be explained by the fact that time after time the man in possession looked up and saw 10 men in the same jerseys as his, totally static. Flat-footed, watching the man with the ball and waiting for him to do something.
It was the absolute and complete antithesis of the football instituted under Pep Guardiola. The antithesis of everything which the Cantera (youth system) guys at Barcelona have been taught all their working lives.
Games can be lost. Under Guardiola there were odd, sometimes embarrassing, losses to Wisla Krakow, Numancia and Mallorca, plus Espanyol and Osasuna at the Camp Nou. But at no time was the team statuesque. Not once did they misplace as many passes or get flustered enough to boot the ball away as often as was the case at the Estadio Jose Zorilla on Saturday. Not once.
My intention isn´t to impose my opinion on the current situation at the Camp Nou; rather, to revert to the guidebook which Guardiola left us.
The flat, "we are trying as hard as we can but there´s nothing in the tank" football which was in evidence against Valladolid was probably worse than anything since Barça lost five and drew four out of 12 games back in the spring of 2008.
That being the case, it´s worth flushing out two fundamentals which, having been introduced by Guardiola shortly after, almost immediately transformed that squad into a tough, athletic, confident and ultimately treble-winning team.
Because his arrival was made so dramatic by the immediate announcement that Ronaldinho, Deco and Samuel Eto´o were not in his plans and could leave, many missed or have since forgotten his promise that "my team will run and run and run."
There were two sides to that. Guardiola believed that the squad wasn´t sufficiently fit or athletic. For the elite, pressurized and world-dominating football he wanted them to play, he felt they were sluggish. It was also fundamental to the young Catalan that without constant running, his team wouldn´t be able to press aggressively and wouldn´t be able to overlap, use the third man move and keep on offering passing options for the man with the ball.
During summer training that year in St. Andrews, Scotland, he ran their legs off. None of them had worked that hard before. Xavi famously recounted that when he, Andres Iniesta and Carles Puyol arrived fresh from winning Euro 2008, he instantly told his colleagues: "This is a train we´d better get aboard right now or it´ll pass us by."
Just in case anyone thinks that "that was then, this is now," I´d point out that in the first training session Guardiola organized at Bayern in summer 2013 he warned all of his players, junior and senior, that "anyone who doesn´t run won´t be in my team."
A second facet of the Guardiola era was the intensity. OK, he wanted the energy, the enthusiasm, the lust for victory to be contagious and self-generating. But if he was a Svengali, he was a sergeant major, too -- make no mistake.
Can you believe, now, that he would instruct Tito Vilanova to phone his stars on a random basis, just to check that on a working night they were at least home, if not in bed, by midnight at the latest?
Take a second and imagine the conversation. "Hi, Leo ... it´s Tito. Sorry, did I wake you ...?"
This intensity meant that every second -- I mean every single second -- of every training session was watched and enforced hawkishly. Verbally, mentally, physically ... emotionally, if appropriate, Guardiola would be right on the shoulder of every single one of his senior footballers.
The result, for the four years before he burned out, was football to dream of. Nothing to do with being a Culé, nothing to do with club colours. Objectively, to the majority of neutrals, this football was the visual equivalent of the choral sections of Beethoven´s "Ode to Joy."
What´s the moral behind all this? Guardiola inherited a talented squad which was flopping -- almost as badly as the current one did on Saturday evening. Albeit the club cleared out and also signed well that summer, his basic remedy was to demand that they work harder athletically and mentally from day one ... ad infinitum.
During this season there have been previous signs -- Ajax away, Osasuna away, Real Sociedad away in the league. Not to mention the depleted state in which Barcelona reached last season´s annihilation by Bayern Munich in the Champions League semifinal.
But Saturday was a new dip, a new low for the brand of football which Barcelona have been purveying.
Finding another Pep Guardiola to instantly succeed the real one was always going to be an impossible ask. Players are permitted to age; it´s not unknown for a board of directors to mishandle a couple of transfer windows. Moreover, it´s not easy for a club when their chosen coach is twice hit with a life-threatening form of cancer.
Institutionally Barcelona have been less well-run, at least football-wise, since 2009 than at any time since 2003. The latter two years of Joan Laporta´s mandate were hedonistic and Sandro Rosell stands accused of helping burn out and discourage Guardiola, unnecessarily driving a wedge between the club and its guru, Johan Cruyff, and appointing a football director in Andoni Zubizarreta whose work pales in comparison to that of his predecessor.
All these things contribute, incrementally, to the type of display that threatens Barcelona´s title defence. Since defeating Elche in the first Liga match of 2014, Tata Martino´s side has taken 14 out of a possible 27 points -- mid-table form at best.
Sadly, part of the decline at Barcelona has included the fact Guardiola blocked almost all media access to training (although he´s been forced to amend that rule slightly at Bayern) and over the past two years, the daily news conferences with a Barça player have dwindled to something of a trickle.
When they speak to you, one-on-one, these are still some of the most interesting, smart and honest players around. But the responsibility of opening up to the media on most working days and, still more integrally important, attending the post-match media mixed zones are extremely helpful thermometers of how things are going.
When some players are uncomfortable that the sessions aren´t intense enough ... you glean it. When a player is sure that he should be playing in place of a rival for that position, you glean it. Sometimes he even says it out loud. When players soft-shoe-shuffle questions about intensity, attitude and the degree to which they are working at maximum level -- you glean it.
The club´s press staff still work hard to get the players to meet their media obligations but there was, once, a board-driven policy that healthy, regular communication between this thriving, open-faced club and the media was a positive and reputation-enhancing strategy.
That´s changed. The more inward-facing a squad becomes, the more likely it is that bad habits, relaxation and lack of intensity will flourish.
What we saw on Saturday, two cornerstones of the entire Barcelona philosophy crumbled, tells a story that the daily work at this club simply isn´t intense enough. Even though he´s paid to take responsibility and ultimately will be held culpable if he doesn´t produce solutions, I´ve a tad of sympathy for Tata Martino.
He´s come from afar, from an utterly different football culture and has helped "lesser" names (Newell´s Old Boys and Paraguay) to demonstrate that the whole can be greater than the sum of the parts. He´s been finding his way at the Camp Nou, mistakes and successes mixed. And there have been some of the latter, make no mistake.
Yet I think that his two biggest challenges, should he remain, are re-instituting the type of physical preparation and on-going training which allow this club to reproduce the work rate on and off the ball which characterized the recent golden era, and to find a way to increase the intensity which was once a daily trademark.
Aside from the multitude of other issues which plague a club beset by what is an incredibly difficult challenge in "real" life and business, not just in football, "managing change" -- whether the likable Martino can properly rise to those two challenges should be the absolute markers as to whether he is or is not the right man for this very, very big job.
More than a clubParticularly since the rise to ascendancy of FC Barcelona I´m often asked about the club´s corporate statement, "Mes Que Un Club."
More than a club. When it was instituted in the late 1960s, it stood for something important and cultural. There were the smallest hints of societal change, the dictator´s grip was slightly less harsh and Franco had about eight years to live.
It was a declaration of identity and not only important but daring at the time.
With the golden era promoted by the teachings of Johan Cruyff, Pep Guardiola, Joan Laporta, Ferran Soriano and embellished by all-time great footballers like Iniesta, Ronaldinho, Michael Laudrup, Hristo Stoichkov, Xavi and Leo Messi (1992-2011), the phrase began to be given new life.
From 2003 the Camp Nou board were fresh, intelligent, young and visionary. A key example is that they were happy to invest money in Unicef so that the club might sport that organisation´s logo on their shirts.
Latterly, as the club has become less visionary, more marketing led and has slid from top gear to neutral in football terms it has sometimes felt that those either tired of Barcelona´s footballing excellence or of how some of us in the media might be perceived to have portrayed them in Mary Poppins, "practically perfect" light are happy now to get out the big stick and swipe at them in a "tall poppy" style retribution.
Thus my attention was caught by a Spanish government minister, Miguel Cardenal, choosing to write an open letter in Spain´s most important "broadsheet" newspaper, El Pais.
Cardenal´s argument seemed to be that FC Barcelona, as a sports club not just as a football club, had been for years achieving things which were centrally important to Spanish culture, Spanish sport and the country´s sense of identity, ambition and purpose.
He noted that this Catalan organisation had produced world champions in a variety of different sports -- basketball, football sala (futsal) and handball, not to mention several of the La Masia trained footballers who were instrumental in winning the World Cup with La Roja.
To give you a taste of the tone of his letter, I´ll reproduce here two passages.
Cardenal wrote:
"FC Barcelona is not only a key asset of the Spain Brand, it is also a reference for sports clubs, committed to home-grown talent as a defining feature. Their academy system has also produced many of our best athletes. Barça resolutely believes in equality and so their women´s teams are also excellent and the club includes sections for athletes with disabilities. Its academy has a commitment to integration and they welcome children arriving in Catalonia from all corners of the world. A few months ago the club was awarded the National Sports Award for best organisation in Spain in 2012, distinguished for its contribution of so many athletes to the London Games.
That is why I cannot accept the excesses which are currently being committed. I would not be doing honour to the responsibility entrusted to me if I remained silent whilst a pillar of our sport and one which has brought us so much is harassed and accused."
These are unusual words for a minister to use, unilaterally, in public. His point of view is that the gulf-stream of media analysis about FC Barcelona as a club is currently aggressive and, to paraphrase him, agenda-driven.
Cardenal uses a stark phrase. "Hopefully, this media kangaroo court trial, which is so damaging to the image of one of our country´s most prestigious institutions, our sport and for Spain´s most admired institutions of our country will come to an end. I ask that everyone, in line with our responsibilities, to contribute to this for the benefit of Spanish sport, which owes so much to this club."
Neither as secretary of state for sport, nor as an expert in sports law, does Cardenal offer judgement on the Neymar case other than to preach "innocent until proven guilty," to note that FC Barcelona are fully up to date with their tax liabilities (extremely rare in La Liga) and are possibly the football world´s biggest taxpayers.
Not being politically agile I don´t know whether, with a mooted referendum on political independence to come later this year in Catalunya, this was a governmental initiative to gain favour in the region of which Barcelona is capital. Nor do I know whether Cardenal´s very unusual action will cost him anything career-wise.
But it strikes me that he´s hit one note exactly right. Whatever workaday problems there are right now and however much it tires some people out to have a dominant sportsman, sportswoman or sports club, we have unquestionably been in a time of absolute excellence and it has benefitted the nation -- not just Catalunya.
He´s also right to say that the mature thing to do is appreciate it now, rather than as some rose-tinted retrospective in 20 years´ time.